Henderson v Ministry of Defence: Without Prejudice Costs Breakdowns Stay Privileged [2026] EWHC 2645 (SCCO)

Detailed Assessment, 2026-10-16

In Henderson v Ministry of Defence [2026] EWHC 2645 (SCCO), Costs Judge Whalan held that the Ministry of Defence could not rely at detailed assessment on without prejudice costs breakdowns that the claimants' solicitors had served to obtain payments on account.

About the author

William Mackenzie, Costs Lawyer at Mackenzie Costs. More about William Mackenzie.

Last reviewed 24 October 2026.

Read the judgment

Overview

Date: 16 October 2026

Judge: Costs Judge Whalan

Court: High Court of Justice, Senior Courts Costs Office

Citation: [2026] EWHC 2645 (SCCO)

Nature of Proceedings: Preliminary issue in two linked detailed assessments of costs in military noise-induced hearing loss claims

Key Issues:

---

In Henderson v Ministry of Defence [2026] EWHC 2645 (SCCO), Costs Judge Whalan held that the Ministry of Defence could not rely at detailed assessment on without prejudice costs breakdowns that the claimants' solicitors had served to obtain payments on account. The breakdowns claimed more than the later certified bills, but the judge found that they recorded costs the claimants had actually incurred. A gap between a receiving party's without prejudice figure and its open bill was not unambiguous impropriety, and fell "a long way short of any form of CPR44.11 misconduct".

---

The Facts

The claimants, Ian Henderson and Jonathan McPherson, claimed damages against the Ministry of Defence for deafness sustained during military service. Their claims belonged to a large cohort of noise-induced hearing loss (NIHL) claims against the MOD. Their solicitors, Hugh James, have conducted about 11,500 such claims, which is believed to be less than 10% of the military NIHL caseload.

In about January 2020 Hugh James agreed an informal protocol with the MOD's solicitors, Keoghs LLP and Plexus Law. After settlement, the claimant would send the defendant a without prejudice schedule or breakdown of costs and disbursements, with a view to an early payment of 50% on account. More than 300 cases went through this process. Over time the MOD used the schedules as a basis for negotiating final costs settlements. Where no settlement followed, which was most cases, the claimant served a Notice of Commencement and a certified bill. In about August 2024 the MOD noticed discrepancies between the schedules and the bills and accused Hugh James of "systematic overcharging". The protocol was abandoned, and every claim since has proceeded by service of a certified bill.

Mr Henderson's claim settled on 12 May 2023 for £65,000 net plus reasonable costs on the standard basis. On 7 July 2023 Hugh James served a without prejudice breakdown of £44,939.52. The MOD paid £24,000 on account on 25 August 2023. The bill, served with a Notice of Commencement on 24 July 2024, totalled £43,813.29 including the costs of drafting, checking and signing it; the relevant net total was £37,261.29. Counsel for the MOD put the difference at £7,678.23, a reduction of 29.4 hours.

Mr McPherson's claim settled on 19 August 2022 for £20,000 plus assessed costs. On 13 February 2023 Hugh James served a without prejudice breakdown of £162,601.36, and on 24 February 2023 the MOD paid £81,300.68 on account. The bill, served on 8 December 2023, totalled £143,117.35, with a relevant net figure of £132,052.75. Counsel for the MOD put the difference at £30,548.61, a reduction of 52.3 hours.

Point 1 of the Points of Dispute in both assessments, headed "Discrepancy to Previous Cost Details", alleged that the gaps suggested misconduct under CPR 44.11. Before it could plead that allegation, the MOD needed permission to put the breakdowns before the court. The judge heard the preliminary issue on 22 July 2026. Mr Andrew Hogan appeared for the claimants and Mr Robin Dunne for the MOD. The detailed assessment hearing is listed for 25 to 29 January 2027.

---

Key Holdings

1. The breakdowns were without prejudice documents

Although the point had been argued in correspondence, at the hearing the parties agreed that the schedules were, on their face, without prejudice documents. Mr Dunne referred to Schering Corporation v Cipla Ltd [2004] EWHC 2587 (Ch), where Laddie J said:

> If a document is marked 'without prejudice', that is some indication that the author intended the document so to be treated as part of a negotiating process, and in many cases a recipient would receive it understanding that that marking indicated that that was the author's intention.

The judge proceeded on that shared footing (at [8]). The real dispute was whether the privilege should be set aside.

2. Unambiguous impropriety is a deliberately high bar

The judge described without prejudice status as a "veil or cloak" of privilege which the court should be slow to remove. One exception applies where exclusion of the evidence "would act as a cloak for… unambiguous impropriety", as Walker LJ put it in Unilever v Procter & Gamble [2002] 1 WLR 2436 (at [9]).

He cited the summary in Passmore on Privilege, which records that since Berry Trade Ltd v Moussavi [2003] EWCA Civ 715 and SIB Ltd v Sincken [2003] EWCA Civ 1630 the exception has not been treated as a broad and flexible rule. The leading authority is Motorola Solutions Inc v Hytera Communications Corp Ltd [2021] EWCA Civ 11. The judge set out passages from the judgment of Males LJ, including this at [61]:

> Thus even when something said without prejudice is contrary to a party's open position, that will not be enough to allow the without prejudice statement to be adduced in evidence unless the statement demonstrably constitutes an abuse of the privilege.

And at [64]:

> Rather, the position should be that the test remains one of unambiguous impropriety. Nothing less will do. That is a test which, deliberately, is difficult to satisfy but the fact that it arises on an interim application is no reason to dilute it.

The passage at [61] bears directly on this case. A difference between a without prejudice figure and an open position is not, without more, an abuse of the privilege.

3. The arguments

The MOD argued that serving schedules "which contain significantly higher costs than are justifiable to induce the paying party to overpay" was a clear example of unambiguous impropriety. It said the schedules overstated the costs actually incurred, that they were designed to push the MOD to settle at a higher level than was justifiable, and that it mattered that the paying party was a publicly funded body facing a very large number of NIHL claims. In Mr Henderson's case, the costs draughtsman acting for Hugh James had made a settlement offer higher than the bill later served. The MOD said that whether the conduct was reckless, negligent or intentional, unambiguous impropriety followed if it suggested CPR 44.11 misconduct.

Mr Dunne cited Ramsey v Instore (2018), in which District Judge Duerden held that a without prejudice costs schedule lost its privilege because it was inaccurate and had been served to start costs negotiations, and GSD v Wardman [2017] EWCA Civ 2144, where the Court of Appeal upheld a District Judge's disallowance of costs for systematic over-inflation in a schedule. He also cited McNamee v LB Brent [2025] EWHC 2612 (SCCO), in which the SCCO set aside without prejudice privilege where an informal statement of costs had "grossly exaggerated" the claimant's true entitlement. The errors there included inflated hourly rates, the wrong fee earner grades and a "massive overstatement" of recoverable time.

The claimants denied any impropriety. Their witness evidence explained that the schedules were filtered summaries of recorded time and disbursements taken from Hugh James's case management system. They were not bills and were not certified, but the rates and time were accurate. When external costs lawyers later drew the certified bills, they used professional judgement about what was likely to be recoverable between the parties and removed items such as routine internal correspondence, funding work, administrative tasks and time that was excessive, duplicated or disproportionate. The breakdown in Mr McPherson's case had wrongly included the costs of a failed disclosure application, but that was corrected in the bill. The claimants said the MOD had chosen to use the schedules for final negotiations, and that the bills were lower because the claimants chose to limit their claims and narrow the issues.

4. The breakdowns recorded costs actually incurred

The judge accepted the claimants' account (at [16]):

> I am satisfied, on the balance of the available evidence, that the without prejudice schedules claimed exclusively costs which the Claimants had actually incurred.

He rejected the allegation that the schedules included costs beyond those incurred, or costs for which the claimants were not liable. He accepted that the bills were reduced because the receiving parties expected challenges on assessment and wanted to narrow the dispute, and that the breakdowns were served mainly to support interim payments. As to the MOD's use of them for final settlement, he said:

> I do not accept that it was the Claimants' intention or purpose to induce final settlement, let alone settlement at an over value.

The wrongly included disclosure costs in Mr McPherson's breakdown were "a genuine, isolated mistake", later corrected, and not evidence of systematic overcharging.

5. Criticism falls short of impropriety

The judge did not clear Hugh James entirely (at [17]):

> This does not mean that the Claimants' solicitors are entirely invulnerable to criticism. More could have been done to rationalise the costs outlined in the (fairly detailed) breakdowns served on the Defendant: this process was subsequently undertaken quite easily by cost draughtsmen with no experience of the day-to-day conduct of the litigation.

He added that once it became clear the MOD was using the breakdowns as the basis for final negotiations, "more could reasonably have been done to have alerted the Defendant to the likely presence of some duplication and disproportionality."

Those criticisms did not reach the threshold:

> The schedules represented the Claimants' actual incurred costs and any inconsistency in the Claimants' without prejudice and subsequent open positions was a long way short of any form of CPR44.11 misconduct.

The judge contrasted McNamee, where a series of basic errors produced an informal schedule that grossly inflated the costs actually incurred. Here there were no basic errors of calculation and no misrepresentation. He concluded that "the Defendant's case falls a long way short of demonstrating unambiguous impropriety", so the claimants could keep the privilege and the MOD could not rely on the breakdowns at the assessment.

---

Practical Implications

For Costs Lawyers

1. The question is whether the figures were true, not whether they changed. The decisive finding was that the breakdowns recorded costs actually incurred. A without prejudice figure that falls when a bill is drawn, because the drafter removes irrecoverable or doubtful time, does not on its own show impropriety. Paying parties who want to rely on McNamee need evidence of false rates, wrong grades or time that was never spent.

2. Points of dispute built on discrepancies need a route to the evidence. The MOD's Point 1 depended on getting the breakdowns admitted. When that failed, the comparison could not be made at assessment. Before pleading a CPR 44.11 point that rests on without prejudice material, consider whether the unambiguous impropriety test can realistically be met.

3. Receiving parties should explain the gap. The claimants won on witness evidence describing how the breakdowns were produced and why the bills were lower. Firms that use informal schedules should be able to show the source of the figures and the reasons for each later reduction.

4. Label informal schedules for what they are. A schedule of recorded time is not a claim for recoverable costs. Saying so when it is served, and warning the paying party of likely duplication if it starts to use the schedule for final settlement, answers the criticism the judge made at [17].

For Litigation Practitioners

1. Payment on account protocols remain useful. The judge accepted that the protocol aimed to secure interim payments without the cost of applications. Bulk litigants can continue such arrangements, but should agree in writing the purpose of the schedules and whether either side may later refer to them.

2. A paying party's own use of a schedule does not change its purpose. The MOD chose to treat the breakdowns as a starting point for final settlement. That did not turn them into representations about recoverability.

3. Rough figures carry risk. The judge noted that costs draughtsmen with no day-to-day involvement found it easy to strip out items the solicitors had left in. Spending a little time on a schedule before it goes out lowers the risk of a misconduct allegation and of a costly preliminary issue.

---

Conclusion

Henderson v Ministry of Defence applies the strict Motorola test to a common costs practice: the informal breakdown served to obtain money on account. The court accepted that the breakdowns were privileged and found that a reduction between the without prejudice figure and the certified bill was explained by the ordinary work of drawing a bill, not by inflation. The decision sits alongside McNamee v LB Brent rather than against it. The difference lies in whether the informal figure represented costs actually incurred.

For the MOD and the firms that act in military NIHL claims, the ruling may matter beyond these two bills, given the size of the cohort and the 300 or more cases dealt with under the protocol. The detailed assessment is listed for January 2027, and the MOD cannot rely on the breakdowns there. The judge said he would consider any further interlocutory consequences of his findings, if necessary, on a date to be fixed. This analysis forms part of Mackenzie Costs' case law coverage for costs lawyers and litigation practitioners at costlawyer.co.uk.

---

Citation: Ian Henderson and Jonathan McPherson v Ministry of Defence [2026] EWHC 2645 (SCCO)

Full judgment available at: National Archives

Related Specialist Support

Related Cases

View all case law updates | Our services | Contact us