Specialist help with Precedent H, points of dispute, replies, negotiations and detailed assessment from Costs Lawyer William Mackenzie.
Send the papers or a short summary. William will confirm the scope, timetable and fee basis before substantive work begins.
No substantive chargeable work begins until the scope and fee basis have been agreed.
Mackenzie Costs is led by Costs Lawyer William Mackenzie, a Legal 500 Next Generation Partner, and supports matters across England and Wales.
A costs budget is a litigation plan expressed in money. The figures have to be defensible phase by phase, and the assumptions underneath them are what make the difference when the budget is argued at a costs and case management conference.
Filing deadlines are strict and the sanction for missing them is severe: a party who files late may be treated as having filed a budget comprising only the applicable court fees. Relief from that position is possible but it is not something to rely on.
The budget discussion report is where most of the negotiation actually happens. Agreeing phases before the hearing narrows what the judge has to decide and usually produces a better figure than arguing everything at once.
A significant development may require an upward or downward budget revision. CPR 3.15A requires prompt submission. The court can include costs incurred since the relevant development, so incurring some costs does not automatically prevent a revision.
On standard basis assessment where a costs management order has been made, CPR 3.18 governs departure from approved or agreed budgeted costs. Overspending a phase requires attention to any good reason for departure; it should not be left until assessment without advice.
Points of dispute must be short and to the point. The practice direction requires them to follow the model form, to identify the item or items in the bill being disputed, and to state concisely the nature and grounds of the dispute. Each point should be numbered and set against the item it attacks.
General complaints that the costs are too high, or long recitals of the history, add length without adding force. A judge reading a provisional assessment on the papers is looking for specific, answerable objections, and points drafted that way are the ones that produce reductions.
Replies are optional. Their permitted scope is points of principle and concessions, including on provisional assessment. The bill and supporting evidence should explain the claim without relying on lengthy item-by-item denials in the replies.
Claims for £75,000 or less are generally assessed provisionally on the papers, with a cap on the costs of that assessment. Larger claims go to a detailed assessment hearing, where the arguments are made in person.
Offers run alongside the whole process. A well-timed offer shifts the costs risk of the assessment itself, and the consequences of beating or failing to beat one are often worth more than the individual items in dispute.
Points of dispute must be short and to the point, follow the model form annexed to the practice direction, identify the item or items in the bill that are disputed, and state concisely the nature and grounds of each dispute. Points should be consecutively numbered and cross referenced to the bill items they challenge. General assertions that the costs are excessive, without identifying items and grounds, do not comply and carry little weight.
Points of dispute are normally due within 21 days after service of the notice of commencement. Check any agreed extension or court order. If none are served, a default costs certificate may be requested once the period has expired. Points served before the certificate is issued prevent its issue under CPR 47.9(5), although late service has separate consequences.
A party who fails to file a budget when required may be treated as having filed a budget comprising only the applicable court fees. Relief from sanctions can be applied for, but it is discretionary and far from guaranteed, so the filing date should be diarised as soon as directions are given.
Yes, significant developments may justify a revision under CPR 3.15A. Submit it promptly with the required particulars. Costs incurred since the development can be included in the variation; delay and the reasons for the change still need careful consideration.
Provisional assessment is a paper assessment used where the costs claimed are £75,000 or less. The judge reads the bill, the points of dispute and the replies and assesses without a hearing. The recoverable costs of that process are capped. Replies remain limited to points of principle and concessions. A party may request an oral hearing within the period specified in CPR 47.15.
Yes. Advocacy at costs and case management conferences, detailed assessment hearings and costs applications is part of the service, and it is normally handled by the same person who prepared the budget or the dispute documents.
Send a costs enquiry | Call 020 4576 8203 | [email protected]