Detailed Assessment

Detailed assessment support for solicitors and litigants, including bills of costs, points of dispute, replies, provisional assessment and assessment hearings.

Mackenzie Costs provides specialist detailed assessment services for solicitors across England and Wales. Led by Costs Lawyer William Mackenzie, who has worked in costs law since 2009 and is listed as a Legal 500 Next Generation Partner, we act on both paying and receiving party matters from inception through to detailed assessment and advocacy.

Detailed Assessment Support

We assist receiving and paying parties through the detailed assessment process, from the notice of commencement and bill of costs through to points of dispute, replies, negotiation, provisional assessment and final hearing.

Receiving Party Work

For receiving parties, we focus on maximising recovery while keeping the bill procedurally compliant and defensible. That includes the treatment of hourly rates, counsel fees, experts, court fees, funding documents, chronology, proportionality and settlement strategy.

Paying Party Work

For paying parties, we identify unreasonable, disproportionate or unrecoverable items and prepare targeted points of dispute. The aim is to reduce the bill without wasting time on weak objections that are unlikely to assist at assessment.

Detailed assessment is the court process that decides how much of a claimed bill of costs is payable. We support receiving and paying parties through each stage, from the notice of commencement and the bill to points of dispute, replies and the assessment hearing.

Who instructs us

Solicitors instruct us for receiving parties who need to recover costs, and for paying parties who need to test a bill. In-house legal teams also send us files where a costs order has been made but the next procedural step is unclear. We work on matters across England and Wales, in the Senior Courts Costs Office and in the county courts.

What you receive

The work can be a single document or the whole assessment. It includes the bill of costs, the notice of commencement, points of dispute, replies, applications for provisional assessment, written advice on likely recovery, and representation at the assessment hearing. Where a settlement is possible, we advise on the figures before more costs are incurred.

How the process runs

The sequence is fixed by CPR Part 47. The receiving party serves the bill and notice of commencement; the paying party serves points of dispute; the receiving party replies; the court lists the assessment or deals with it provisionally. Each step has a time limit. We confirm where the case stands, what is due and who needs to act before drafting anything.

Common issues

The usual problems are late service, an incomplete bill, points of dispute that do not engage with individual items, and replies that do not answer the objections. Proportionality and hourly rates are commonly challenged. An early view of the strengths and weaknesses usually saves more than it costs.

Questions about detailed assessment

What are the stages of detailed assessment?

Notice of commencement and bill, points of dispute, replies, then provisional assessment or an oral hearing. The court gives directions for each stage and the parties must comply within the time limits.

Do you act for paying parties?

Yes. We review the bill, prepare points of dispute and advise on the reductions that are realistic, so that effort goes on the points the court is likely to accept.

How long does detailed assessment take?

It depends on the court, the size of the bill and whether the case is dealt with provisionally or at an oral hearing. We set out the likely timetable at the start so you can plan around the listed steps.

Related Services

Get in touch to discuss how we can help with your detailed assessment requirements.

View all services | Case law updates | Contact us