Funding & CFAs, 2026-11-09
In Alphier Capital v Blyvoor Gold [2026] EWCA Civ 1432 the Court of Appeal upheld a US$2.25 million success fee for a finance broker that had not introduced the investor. Where two brokers worked jointly, the contract required only that the broker's own work had a real world effect on obtaining the funding.
William Mackenzie, Costs Lawyer at Mackenzie Costs. More about William Mackenzie.
Last reviewed 11 November 2026.
Date: 9 November 2026
Judge: Lord Justice Foxton (Lord Justice Butcher and Lord Justice Miles agreeing)
Court: Court of Appeal (Civil Division), on appeal from Mr Justice Richards, [2026] EWHC 244 (Ch)
Citation: [2026] EWCA Civ 1432
Nature of Proceedings: Appeal against an award of a US$2.25 million success fee to a finance broker under an engagement letter varied by a later three-party agreement
Key Issues:
Hearing date: 27 October 2026
Representation: Richard Power KC (instructed by Mishcon de Reya LLP) for the Appellant; Arnold Ayoo and Weishi Yang (instructed by Three Graces Legal) for the Respondent
---
In Alphier Capital Two LLP v Blyvoor Gold Capital (Pty) Ltd [2026] EWCA Civ 1432, the Court of Appeal upheld an award of US$2.25 million to a finance broker as a success fee, although another broker had introduced the investor and done most of the work of closing the deal. The decision is not a costs judgment. It is a decision on when a contingent fee is earned, and it will interest anyone who drafts or litigates fees that depend on an outcome. The court held that the contract required the broker's own work to have a "real world effect" on obtaining the funding, that this was a low threshold, and that a success fee can lawfully exceed the value of the work that earned it.
---
Blyvoor, a junior mining company, bought a disused gold mine in South Africa in 2016 and set out to raise the money to reopen it. It retained two brokers on non-exclusive terms. Exotix, a regulated investment bank with a large back office, was engaged on 1 March 2018 under an engagement letter ("the EEL"). Legacy Hill, described by the court as "essentially a two-person operation", was engaged on 15 March 2018 under a similar letter.
Under the EEL, Exotix earned a placement fee of 5% on the completion of an investment by an "Exotix Investor", meaning an investor introduced by Exotix. By the end of the trial it was common ground that this required Exotix to be the effective cause of the financing (at [5] and [15]).
Legacy Hill then introduced Orion Resource Partners, a major mining investor, which quickly became the focus of the exercise. As matters stood, Exotix could earn nothing from a deal with Orion. But Exotix had modelling and back-office capacity that Legacy Hill lacked. In late March or early April 2018 the three parties signed a Tripartite Agreement under which the two brokers would "jointly pursue" the Orion funding. It replaced the fee clause in the EEL, for Orion funding only, with an initial fee of 3% and a subsequent fee of 0.75% for Exotix. Legacy Hill was to receive 2% and 0.5%.
The deal proved straightforward. A term sheet was signed on 23 April 2018 and final funding agreements in August 2018. Legacy Hill led the communications with Orion. Exotix analysed Orion's proposed structure, advised on gold offtake pricing, reviewed the term sheet and prepared financial modelling. Blyvoor refused to pay Exotix. Proceedings were issued on 1 March 2023, and Richards J awarded the fee.
---
The judge rejected both extreme positions. Exotix argued that once it had provided services to the joint endeavour and funding was obtained, the fee was due whatever effect its work had. Blyvoor argued that Exotix had to be an effective cause of Orion providing funding, expressly or by implication.
The judge located the surviving causal requirement in paragraph 1.1(e) of the EEL, the obligation to "help place the Investments", read after the Tripartite Agreement as an obligation to help place them with Orion. That required Exotix's individual actions to have "a real world effect on securing the funding from Orion" (at [22], citing the judgment below at [97] and [106]). He found the test met.
Blyvoor did not pursue its implied term case on appeal, and Exotix did not seek to revive its own argument. The appeal was therefore a question of construction, decided on the principles in Arnold v Britton [2015] AC 1619 (at [30]).
---
Blyvoor's main argument was that the judge could not find an effective cause requirement in the original EEL without finding an equivalent requirement after the variation. Foxton LJ rejected this.
He reviewed the authorities on effective cause in agency, including Nahum v Royal Holloway and Bedford New College [1999] EMLR 252 and the passage in Bowstead & Reynolds that an agent "does not have to complete or even take part in the negotiations". The original requirement in the EEL came from the fact that only an investor introduced by Exotix would trigger the fee. He also noted, citing MSM Consulting Ltd v United Republic of Tanzania [2009] EWHC 121 (QB), that the main reason for implying such a term is to reduce the risk of the client paying two commissions.
Neither feature survived the Tripartite Agreement. Exotix could no longer introduce Orion, and the agreement contemplated both brokers being paid on the same funding (at [39]). The conclusion at [40]:
> "The issue of what Exotix would have to do or achieve to obtain commission under the Tripartite Agreement was, therefore, a fundamentally different one from what it would have had to do or achieve to obtain payment under the EEL save that in both cases, the finance had to be obtained."
If any effective cause requirement remained, it was "an attenuated one" (at [42]). The court also declined to read in a "but for" test. Requiring each of two joint brokers to show that its own work made the difference would have encouraged them to take work from each other or duplicate it (at [43]).
---
Blyvoor argued that Exotix could not "help place" the investment if all it did was bring Blyvoor to the point of accepting Orion's offer, without changing Orion's conduct. The court gave four reasons for rejecting that at [45]. The ordinary meaning of the words includes "helping Blyvoor assess and get comfortable with a funding proposal which was then closed". The distinction would put a premium on work facing Orion, which the brokers were not meant to compete for. It sat badly with the finding that Blyvoor brought Exotix in partly because financial modelling was needed and Legacy Hill could not do it. And it would give a different legal result to analysis showing that Orion's price was acceptable and analysis leading to a counter-offer, a distinction with no basis in the words or the context.
---
Blyvoor relied on the pricing. Exotix's share was half as large again as Legacy Hill's, which suggested the parties expected a contribution of that order. In the event Exotix did considerably less than Legacy Hill.
Foxton LJ held that Blyvoor's expectations explained why it signed the agreement, but that it had not contracted on the basis that the fee depended on the work matching those expectations (at [47]). He approved the judge's observation that, since little work was needed by either broker to close the deal, little was needed for Exotix's work to help place the investment. He then said this of contingent fees at [48]:
> "It is in the nature of such arrangements that there will be occasions when the broker obtains a fee which significantly exceeds the objective value of the work, just as there will be many occasions when work of considerable objective value is done but no fee received."
---
Ground 3 attacked the finding that Exotix's work in fact had a real world effect. That required Blyvoor to show that the conclusion "cannot reasonably be explained or justified", the test in Henderson v Foxworth Investments Ltd [2014] UKSC 41 at [67]. The judge had identified three pieces of work: explaining the 8-day quotation period in the gold offtake terms, written comments on the term sheet that were reflected in the mark-up sent to Orion, and modelling Orion's offer against expected gold prices. Those findings were a sufficient basis for his conclusion (at [53] to [54]). The appeal was dismissed on all three grounds.
---
1. The trigger for a contingent fee is a question of construction. The court asked what the contract required the adviser to do or achieve, read in its commercial setting. It did not ask what the work was worth. The same discipline applies to any fee that depends on a defined result.
2. A variation can change the trigger without saying so in terms. The Tripartite Agreement replaced only the fee clause, yet the effect was to remove the introduction requirement on which the effective cause test rested. When a retainer is varied, read the definitions the fee clause depends on, not only the clause itself.
3. Disproportion between fee and work is not an answer to a contractual success fee. The passage at [48] is a clear appellate statement that the bargain includes the risk of unpaid work on failed deals and the chance of a large fee on a quick one.
1. Where two advisers share a mandate, say what each must contribute to be paid. The dispute arose because the agreement fixed the split but not the threshold. A sentence defining the contribution required would have avoided three years of litigation.
2. "Help" is a low bar. A client who wants the fee to depend on the adviser changing the counterparty's position, or on work of a stated scope, must say so expressly.
3. An appeal against an evaluative finding needs more than a different view of the facts. Ground 3 failed on the Henderson v Foxworth test because the judge had explained his conclusion and tied it to specific work.
---
Alphier Capital v Blyvoor Gold confirms that a success fee is earned when the contractual trigger is met, and that the trigger is found by reading the contract as varied, in its setting. Where two advisers are engaged to pursue one transaction together, the usual reasons for an effective cause requirement fall away, and a requirement to "help" will be met by work that had a real effect on the deal being done, including work that helped the client decide to accept it.
The fee here was US$2.25 million for work the court accepted was limited. The Court of Appeal saw nothing commercially unreal in that. The broker took the risk of earning nothing, and the client agreed the percentage before anyone knew how easy the deal would be.
The judgment is short and cites few authorities, by design. Its value lies in the reasoning on how a variation alters a fee trigger and in the statement at [48] on the nature of contingent fees.
---
Citation: Alphier Capital Two LLP v Blyvoor Gold Capital (Pty) Ltd [2026] EWCA Civ 1432
Full judgment available at: National Archives