Payments on account of costs: what the High Court ordered in 2026

The Mackenzie Costs 2026 review of payments on account read 17 decisions in 13 High Court judgments. The median payment was 67.1% of the costs claimed.

Updated 10 November 2026

When a court orders costs to be assessed, CPR 44.2(8) requires it to order a reasonable sum on account unless there is good reason not to. The rule gives no figure. This page records what judges ordered in practice, with each decision linked to the judgment.

Findings

Payment on account as a share of costs claimed

GroupDecisionsMedianLowestHighest
All decisions1767.1%26.8%81.0%
Approved costs budget579.6%71.7%81.0%
Schedule, statement or estimate of costs1260.0%26.8%75.0%
Indemnity basis875.5%53.9%81.0%
Standard basis660.0%49.1%75.0%

The decisions

Each row is one payment on account. Where a judgment fixed payments for more than one party, each has its own row.

CaseReceiving partyBasisBudgetCosts claimedOrderedShareHow the judge reached it
Teixeira v Moaven [2026] EWHC 1542 (Ch)Claimant and her childrenindemnityNo£229,361£172,02175.0%The judge started from 80% of the costs estimate and took off a further 5%.
Teixeira v Moaven [2026] EWHC 1542 (Ch)Independent administratorsindemnityNo£455,544£318,88070.0%70% of the costs summary, after the judge left out most of the costs described as administrative.
Ocorian Private Trustees (Jersey) Ltd v McGeoch [2026] EWHC 1693 (Ch)AppellantstandardNo£216,000£106,00049.1%About 60% of the costs in certified schedules and about 40% of the costs that were not certified.
Hoffman v Finalto Group Ltd [2026] EWHC 1702 (Comm)ClaimantsstandardNo60.0%60% of the two thirds of their costs that the claimants were awarded. The judgment does not state the sum.
Importers Service Corporation v Aliotta [2026] EWHC 1969 (Ch)ClaimantsindemnityYes£801,422£608,75676.0%90% of budgeted costs and 60% of the other costs incurred.
Winehouse v Parry [2026] EWHC 1970 (KB)First defendantindemnityYes£715,362£569,33179.6%90% of budgeted costs and 75% of unbudgeted costs.
Winehouse v Parry [2026] EWHC 1970 (KB)Second defendantindemnityYes£487,132£394,52281.0%90% of budgeted costs and 75% of unbudgeted costs.
Abbott v Ministry of Defence [2026] EWHC 2083 (KB)ClaimantsstandardNo£5,030,390£2,515,19550.0%50% of the 60% share of common costs awarded. The court had no certified schedule or signed bill.
Car-Wizard Ltd v Vixen Surface Treatments Ltd [2026] EWHC 2177 (Ch)ClaimantindemnityYes£265,421£214,00080.6%80% of budgeted costs and 65% of incurred costs, against an order for 90% of the claimant's costs.
Quidpay Finance Ltd v Settlego Solutions Ltd [2026] EWHC 2199 (Ch)Claimant, injunction applicationstandardNo£188,970£113,38260.0%60% of the 65% share of a statement of costs of £290,722.50.
Quidpay Finance Ltd v Settlego Solutions Ltd [2026] EWHC 2199 (Ch)Defendant, preliminary issue applicationsnot statedNo£15,503£7,00045.2%60% was sought. The judge ordered less because the hourly rates claimed were about 235% of the guideline rates.
Lawrence v Associated Newspapers Ltd [2026] EWHC 2207 (KB)DefendantindemnityYes£13,313,299£9,544,35571.7%90% of approved budgeted costs and 60% of costs incurred before the budget.
Gomes v AMG Financial Management Ltd [2026] EWHC 2334 (Comm)DefendantstandardNo£25,868£19,40075.0%75% of the 75% share of costs of £34,491 set out in statements of costs.
Servicios de Salud v Viva Enterprises Ltd [2026] EWHC 2333 (Ch)ClaimantstandardNo60.0%60% of the costs in the claimant's schedule, against an order for 55% of its costs. The judgment does not state the sum.
Amaal Ventures Ltd v Eros Ltd [2026] EWHC 2259 (Ch)Claimantsnot statedNo£1,676,915£450,00026.8%£950,000 was sought. There was no costs budget and the claimants were shell companies.
Amaal Ventures Ltd v Eros Ltd [2026] EWHC 2259 (Ch)Defendant, consequentials hearingnot statedNo£111,703£75,00067.1%The defendant was awarded 35% of a schedule of £319,150.
Hattons of London Ltd v The Knightsbridge Collection Ltd [2026] EWHC 2793 (KB)ClaimantindemnityNo£510,292£275,00053.9%£357,204.51 was sought as 70% of the costs claimed. The judge thought that a little high.

What the decisions show

An approved budget is the strongest ground for a high payment. Judges treated 90% of budgeted costs as the norm, following Thomas Pink Ltd v Victoria's Secret UK Ltd [2014] EWHC 3258 (Ch), because the court will not depart from an approved budget on assessment without good reason.

Costs outside the budget were treated with more caution. Incurred and unbudgeted costs drew between 60% and 75%, with the higher figures where costs were on the indemnity basis.

The quality of the costs information mattered. In Ocorian v McGeoch the judge allowed a higher share of costs in certified schedules than of costs that were not certified. In Abbott v Ministry of Defence the court had no certified schedule or signed bill, and ordered 50%.

Hourly rates were examined even at this stage. In Quidpay Finance v Settlego Solutions the judge ordered £7,000 against £15,503.10 claimed, because the rates were about 235% of the guideline hourly rates.

The lowest payment, in Amaal Ventures v Eros, was made where there was no costs budget and the receiving parties were shell companies. The judge sought to limit the risk that the payment would exceed the sum due on assessment.

Method

The review covers judgments of the High Court and the Court of Appeal published by The National Archives and dated between June and early November 2026. Judgments were identified by a search of the full text for payments on account of costs, and each one was read. Every decision that met the test below was made in the King's Bench Division, the Chancery Division or the Commercial Court, between 30 June and 23 October 2026.

A decision is included where the judge fixed a payment on account in that judgment and stated either the costs claimed or the percentage ordered. Decisions are left out where the sum was agreed between the parties, where the amount was left to later submissions, or where the judgment states the payment but not the costs claimed.

The percentage is the payment divided by the costs claimed that fall within the costs order. Where the court awarded a party a proportion of its costs, the percentage is measured against that proportion. In two decisions the judgment gives the percentage and not the sums.

The sample is 17 decisions. The figures for each group rest on between 5 and 12 decisions and should be read with that in mind.

Common questions

What percentage of costs will the court order as a payment on account?

There is no fixed percentage. The Mackenzie Costs 2026 review of payments on account found a median of 67.1% of the costs claimed across 17 High Court decisions, with a range from 26.8% to 81.0%.

Does an approved costs budget increase the payment on account?

Yes. The Mackenzie Costs 2026 review of payments on account found a median of 79.6% where the judge worked from an approved budget, against 60.0% where there was only a schedule, statement or estimate of costs. Judges commonly ordered 90% of budgeted costs.

Is a payment on account higher when costs are on the indemnity basis?

In this sample, yes. The median was 75.5% on the indemnity basis and 60.0% on the standard basis.

Which rule governs payments on account of costs?

CPR 44.2(8). Where the court orders a party to pay costs subject to detailed assessment, it will order that party to pay a reasonable sum on account of costs, unless there is good reason not to do so.

Citing these figures

These figures may be quoted with attribution to Mackenzie Costs and a link to this page. William Mackenzie is a Costs Lawyer regulated by the Costs Lawyer Standards Board.

Guide to detailed assessment | Practice guides | Contact Mackenzie Costs