Corporation Leasing v Irwin Mitchell: Settlement Advice, Reliance on Counsel and Fees Claimed as Damages [2026] EWHC 2785 (KB)

Solicitor & Client, 2026-10-30

In Corporation Leasing & Finance Limited v Irwin Mitchell LLP [2026] EWHC 2785 (KB), Mansfield J dismissed a professional negligence claim brought by a commercial lender against the solicitors who had settled two sets of proceedings on its behalf.

About the author

William Mackenzie, Costs Lawyer at Mackenzie Costs. More about William Mackenzie.

Last reviewed 5 November 2026.

Read the judgment

Overview

Date: 30 October 2026

Judge: Mr Justice Mansfield

Court: High Court of Justice, King's Bench Division

Citation: [2026] EWHC 2785 (KB)

Nature of Proceedings: Trial of a professional negligence claim by a commercial lender against its former solicitors, arising from the settlement of an order for sale claim and of a negligence claim against the lender's earlier solicitors

Key Issues:

Case No: KB-2024-000735

Hearing dates: 22, 23, 24, 27, 28 and 30 July 2026

Representation: James Pickering KC (instructed by Colman Coyle LLP) for the Claimant; Francis Bacon (instructed by Kennedys LLP) for the Defendant

---

In Corporation Leasing & Finance Limited v Irwin Mitchell LLP [2026] EWHC 2785 (KB), Mansfield J dismissed a professional negligence claim brought by a commercial lender against the solicitors who had settled two sets of proceedings on its behalf. The High Court held that the solicitors were not negligent in advising settlement, were entitled to rely on counsel's advice, and caused no loss. The judgment applies the Langsam v Beachcrofts line of authority on settlement advice and the Perry v Raleys requirement that a lost claim be an honest one. It also rejected a claim to recover £240,759 of the solicitors' own fees as damages, observing that the bills had not been challenged in time on a solicitor and own client assessment and that credit had not been given for £90,000 of those costs recovered from the opponent.

---

The Facts

Corporation Leasing & Finance Limited ("CLF") describes itself as a provider of invoice discounting facilities. It lent to the business of a Mr Raby. In 2012 Mr Raby and his partner, Ms McCann, gave CLF a guarantee and legal charge over their jointly owned house in Esher. Clause 13 of that deed (the "Certification Clause") provided that a certificate by an official of CLF as to the sums due would be "binding and conclusive" in any legal proceedings ([20]). The business collapsed within months, Mr Raby was made bankrupt, and in October 2012 CLF demanded £881,261.38 ([28]).

CLF's original solicitors ("RPL") brought an order for sale claim in the Central London County Court in 2014. Ms McCann defended it on grounds of undue influence and misrepresentation and put CLF to proof of the debt. Over the following two years RPL repeatedly told CLF that it would have to prove the debt with documents. Very little was produced. In April 2016 Ms McCann's solicitors alleged in correspondence that the debt was fraudulent, RPL came off the record shortly before trial, and the trial was adjourned with CLF ordered to pay the costs thrown away ([103], [110], [118]).

Irwin Mitchell LLP ("IM") was instructed in September 2016. On the advice of IM and counsel, Faisal Sadiq, CLF compromised Ms McCann's security for costs application and then settled the order for sale claim for £270,000, with its interests in the Esher property and a property in Turkey released. Terms were agreed in October 2016 and the settlement agreement was signed on 19 May 2017 ([147] to [151]).

IM then issued a professional negligence claim against RPL in January 2018, alleging failures over the Etridge guidelines when the charge was taken and a failure to advise CLF to accept Ms McCann's settlement offers made in late 2015 and early 2016. Throughout, IM and both counsel (Mr Sadiq and later Hugh Jackson) advised that the claim was likely to fail because CLF could not prove that it had lent the money. On 22 May 2019 the claim was settled. RPL agreed to pay CLF's costs, which CLF later accepted at £90,000, and RPL abandoned its claim for unpaid fees of £151,909.30 and returned £9,000 held on account ([201]).

CLF then sued IM. By the end of a six-day trial it pursued four allegations: failure to plead the Certification Clause or the ledger evidence; negligent settlement advice; failure to plead an "Additional Liability Claim" against RPL; and failure to include an interest clause in the order for sale settlement ([37] to [44]).

---

1. Settlement Advice Is Judged Without Hindsight

Mansfield J began with the principles in Langsam v Beachcrofts LLP [2012] EWCA Civ 1230. Advice on settlement involves weighing matters that are difficult to predict and on which opinions differ, and lawyers giving that advice are not to be judged with hindsight ([47]). Arden LJ in Langsam had approved the passage from Karpenko v Paroian, Courey & Houston (1980) 117 DLR (3rd) 383, which concludes:

> In my view it would be only in the case of some egregious error that negligence would be found.

The judge also cited Griffin v Kingsmill [2001] EWCA Civ 934, where Stuart-Smith LJ said that in a complex case settlement advice "cannot be impugned" unless it was "blatantly wrong, i.e. such as no competent and experienced practitioner would give it" ([49]), and Simon Brown LJ's warning in Ogilvy & Mather Ltd v Rubinstein Callingham Polden & Gale that such claims "should be treated with some circumspection" if satellite litigation is to be kept within limits ([48]).

On reliance on counsel, the judge summarised Langsam at [50]. A solicitor does not abdicate responsibility by instructing counsel, but is in general entitled to rely on counsel properly instructed. The solicitor must not do so blindly and must reject advice that is "obviously or glaringly wrong", judged in the light of any specialist expertise the solicitor has.

These principles decided the case. The court found that the advice of both counsel was reasonable, that IM had properly instructed them, and that IM was entitled to rely on what they said ([283], [305]).

---

2. A Certification Clause Would Not Have Carried the Day

CLF's main argument was that the Certification Clause made a certificate conclusive absent manifest error or fraud, that no fraud had been pleaded, and that IM should therefore have relied on the clause rather than treating proof of the debt as a fatal weakness ([223]).

The judge rejected this. Mr Sadiq had advised that, although fraud was not pleaded, the case was heading that way and that pleading the clause would itself prompt a plea of fraud ([228], [231]). The court found that assessment realistic:

> Part of counsel's task is to anticipate the way an argument may develop.

At [232] the judge said that "It would have been foolhardy to rely simply on the Certification Clause, rather than seeking to prove the debt (which ought to have been a simple exercise)." Any trial would have considered the evidence of the debt alongside the undue influence and misrepresentation defence, which attacked the very deed containing the clause. It was "wholly unrealistic" to suggest the court would compartmentalise those issues or regard itself as bound by a certificate in the face of evidence that the debt could not be proved ([233] to [234]).

The judge added that no certificate had ever been produced or pleaded, and doubted that the 30 October 2012 demand was one. Of the suggestion that a certificate could be issued at any time, he said at [237]:

> The notion that, at any time after the event, even now, CLF could simply produce a certificate which would be binding (absent manifest error or fraud) is highly unattractive.

---

3. Weak Evidence of the Debt Justified Pessimistic Advice

The court examined the documents CLF said proved its lending: several versions of a ledger, 11 pages of "bank statements" disclosed in April 2016, and discounting reports. The statements identified no bank, account holder or account number, and two copies carried different redactions ([251] to [252]). The "Master Ledger" first appeared in May 2019, seven years after the demand ([243]). A single sales invoice was disclosed on the first day of the trial before Mansfield J, an explanation for which the judge described as "absurd" ([258]). He also found that a "vouching" exercise said to have been agreed with Ms McCann's solicitors never took place ([130]).

The judge did not decide what the documents showed or whether there was any fraudulent scheme ([259]). The question was whether it was negligent for IM and counsel to regard the evidence as insufficient. He held that it was not:

> When IM and counsel formed the view that the evidence as to debt was unreliable, they were well justified in that view.

His assessment of the client is also relevant to any settlement advice claim. At [180] he said: "I have formed the distinct impression that Mr Thornton simply did not listen to advice that he did not want to hear."

---

4. A Lost Settlement Claim Must Still Be an Honest One

CLF's strongest point appeared to be the "Subsequent Etridge Breach Claim": that RPL should have advised acceptance of Ms McCann's early 2016 offers. CLF said this was a lost opportunity to settle and did not depend on proving the debt, and Mr Jackson accepted as much in cross-examination ([262] to [263]).

The judge did not accept that answer as a complete analysis. Applying Perry v Raleys [2019] 2 WLR 636, where Lord Briggs held that a claimant must prove that the lost claim would have been an honest one, the judge accepted Mr Bacon's submission that the burden lay on CLF ([53], [265]). If the court in the claim against RPL had found that the debt could not be proved, or found fraud or illegality, the whole claim would have been tainted:

> It would be wholly unrealistic to think that CLF might fail to establish its claim was based on a genuine underlying debt but then recover for the loss of a chance to have settled an unmeritorious, even fraudulent, claim.

The judge added at [266] that, even if the claim were viable on its own, a lawyer would be entitled to think it too dangerous to go to trial and risk adverse findings on the rest of the claim. IM had not overlooked the point: Mr Sachs regarded it as the stronger part of the case ([267]). There was also little prospect that proper advice in early 2016 would have produced a concluded deal, given that CLF was then bullish and Ms McCann's solicitors were developing their fraud allegations ([272]).

---

5. No Duty to Plead a Claim the Client Never Instructed

The Additional Liability Claim alleged that CLF had told RPL in 2012 to make Ms McCann personally liable for any shortfall if she delayed enforcement. The judge found that CLF never gave IM instructions to that effect, and rejected the argument that instructions could be inferred from the £1,239,168 figure pleaded as loss ([274] to [276]):

> Therefore, IM was not negligent in failing to bring a claim about which it was not instructed.

When the point surfaced in 2019, both counsel advised that an amendment would fail on the merits. That was sensible advice ([277]). The judge went further and found that the instruction to RPL had never been given, and that Ms McCann would not realistically have agreed to such a term in any event ([278] to [280]).

---

6. The Interest Clause: A Commercial Term for a Commercial Client

The only remaining complaint about the order for sale settlement was that IM had not proposed interest on the £270,000, which was paid only after the property transfers were completed. The judge held at [286] that IM was not negligent. There was no reason to think Ms McCann or Mr Raby would have agreed; the parties could be taken to have priced in the risk of delay; CLF faced likely defeat on security for costs and at trial; and CLF had months to consider the terms before signing. He added:

> CLF would not have been in need of legal advice to think of the protection of an interest provision.

The pleaded case was also incoherent. It sought interest if the sum was not paid "in accordance with the settlement agreement", but the agreement had no payment date and there was no breach. At trial the case shifted to interest from signature, which was not pleaded:

> A clause which triggers interest from the date a party defaults is very different from a clause that triggers interest from the date an agreement is signed.

No rate or figure for the interest claim was ever pleaded or proved ([287], [304]).

---

7. Fees Paid to the Solicitors Are Not Recoverable as Wasted Expenditure

Although he had found no negligence, the judge addressed quantum briefly and found the losses claimed "poorly thought through and, in large part, lacking in evidence" ([289]). The pleaded base loss of £1,464,860.87 had no supporting calculation, and by closing CLF's own figure had fallen to £725,000 before any discount ([292], [294]). The alternative claim based on the early 2016 offers involved what the judge called "a double loss of a chance assessment" ([296]). A claim for loss of use of money at an average return of 12.68% was "without any evidential basis" ([298] to [300]).

The point of most interest to costs practitioners concerns paragraph 44 of the Amended Particulars of Claim, which sought the return of £240,759 in fees paid to IM. The judge rejected it at [302] for several reasons. If CLF recovered damages on the footing that IM should have achieved a better settlement, it would have paid IM's fees for that work anyway, so the claim was double recovery. If CLF suffered no loss, there was no basis for recovering the fees. And:

> IM did the work, and I was told that there was no in time challenge for its bills to be assessed on a solicitor/own client basis.

IM had achieved a settlement of the order for sale claim now criticised only in a minor respect, and it was not said that the negligence claim would never have been brought: "It cannot be said that the fees were wasted." The judge also accepted at [303] that the figure was inflated because it gave no credit for the £90,000 of IM's costs that RPL had paid under the settlement. Mr Thornton accepted that credit was due, and no explanation was offered for leaving it out.

---

Practical Implications

For Costs Lawyers

1. A fees claim dressed as damages is not a substitute for assessment. The court noted that IM's bills had not been challenged in time on a solicitor and own client basis, and treated the work as done and not wasted. A client unhappy with its solicitors' charges should consider assessment while it remains available, rather than relying on recovering the fees later as damages.

2. Give credit for inter partes recoveries. Where costs have been recovered from an opponent, any claim against the client's own solicitors for those fees must deduct them. Omitting the £90,000 here was an obvious inflation that damaged the claim's credibility.

3. Watch for double recovery. A claim for a better settlement and a claim for the return of the fees incurred in achieving the settlement are inconsistent. Paying parties and defendant solicitors should take the point at the pleading stage.

4. Document the source of every figure. The base loss, the loss of use claim and the interest claim all failed in part because no calculation or evidence supported them. The same discipline applies to any figure advanced on assessment or in a solicitor and own client dispute.

For Litigation Practitioners

1. Settlement advice is protected unless it is egregiously wrong. The Langsam, Karpenko and Griffin line of authority sets a high bar. Advice that a weak claim should be settled for what can be obtained will rarely be impugned where it is reasoned and recorded.

2. Record the advice and send the notes. IM's defence succeeded largely because conference notes and advice letters showed what was said and that the client received it. The client's evidence that he had not seen the notes did not survive the documents ([139]).

3. Reliance on counsel requires proper instructions. The court rejected the suggestion that Mr Jackson lacked the papers or time to advise, noting four conferences over almost four weeks ([269]). Solicitors should ensure counsel has the whole case before relying on counsel's view of it.

4. A certification or conclusive evidence clause will not survive a credible fraud challenge. Where the deed itself is attacked, or the evidence suggests the debt cannot be proved, the court is likely to look behind the certificate. Lenders should prove their debt with primary records.

5. Loss of a chance claims inherit the weaknesses of the underlying claim. Under Perry v Raleys the claimant must show the lost claim was honest. A component that appears independent of the problem evidence may still fail if the trial would have explored that evidence.

6. Commercial clients are expected to protect their own commercial terms. A sophisticated lender could not blame its solicitors for failing to suggest an interest provision it was well able to think of itself.

---

Conclusion

Corporation Leasing v Irwin Mitchell is a firm application of the settled principles on settlement advice and reliance on counsel. Mansfield J found that IM and both counsel formed realistic views that the claim against RPL was very likely to fail because CLF could not prove its debt, that the settlement reached was reasonable, and that a trial would in all likelihood have left CLF far worse off ([306]). The certification clause, the separate settlement-offer claim and the unpleaded additional liability claim did not change that analysis.

For costs practitioners the most useful passages are those on quantum. A claim to recover a solicitor's fees as wasted expenditure failed where the bills had not been challenged on assessment in time, the work had been done, and no credit had been given for costs recovered from the opponent. The judgment is also a reminder that loss figures without calculation or evidence will be given no weight.

The decision will be cited by solicitors defending settlement advice claims, particularly where the client's own evidence or documents were the cause of the weakness. Mackenzie Costs will continue to report on decisions at the boundary of professional negligence and solicitor and client costs on costlawyer.co.uk.

---

Citation: Corporation Leasing & Finance Limited v Irwin Mitchell LLP [2026] EWHC 2785 (KB)

Full judgment available at: National Archives

Related Specialist Support

Related Cases

View all case law updates | Our services | Contact us